Two most recruitable agent personas

Most brokerages recruit the wrong agents at the wrong time.

By Diana Zaya - Founder of Maverick Systems 


"Is anyone in my market actually recruiting?"


A few months ago, a broker I had spoken with earlier in the year called me back. He was interested in Maverick but still on the fence, and he had one question: "Are people in my market actually recruiting?" I told him I'd run the numbers.


Over the previous 12 months, about 13% of agents in his market had changed brokerages. Another 9% were brand new to the business. There was plenty of movement. He was surprised. "Well," he said, "I'm not recruiting anybody."


So I asked him three questions. Who is responsible for recruiting? What do they do consistently? And what tools help them do it? His answers were the same ones I hear from most brokers. The market is moving, recruiting time is short, and nothing tells them where to spend it.


We dug into our national agent data to answer that question. Here is what it shows, and the two agent personas we believe deserve your limited recruiting time.


Recruiters chase veterans. Agents move early.


The Inman Intel Index asked agents a simple question: "Were you recruited in the last 60 days?" The answers climb with tenure. Fewer than 30% of first-year agents said yes, while agents with 9 to 15 years in the business said yes more than 70% of the time.


Now compare that to who actually moves. Our national data shows that switching peaks in an agent's first year, at about 14%, and falls nearly every year after that. By year 12, it is close to 5%.


That is the gap. Most recruiting effort goes to the agents least likely to move, while the agents most likely to move hear from almost no one. Veterans get recruited heavily because they are visible. Their names sit at the top of the production report, and every competitor is working from the same list. Early-career agents are harder to spot, so most firms don't try.


Listings anchor agents. Empty boards open the window.


An agent with active listings is not going anywhere. Moving in the middle of a pipeline means risking deals, sellers, and commission. To measure this, we froze time on agents nationally, looked at their pipeline at that moment, and tracked who switched brokerages over the next 12 months.


Share of agents who switched brokerages within 12 months

Last closing

3+ active listings

1–2 active listings

0 active listings

Within 3 months

2.7%

5.1%

8.2%

3–6 months ago

6.9%

8.3%

12.1%

6–12 months ago

11.8%

12.5%

15.6%


The busy, anchored agent switches at 2.7%. The agent with no listings and no closing in six months switches at 15.6%, nearly six times the rate. The lesson is timing. The same agent can be a poor prospect in March and a strong one in September, and the only thing that changed is their pipeline.


The bigger the producer, the louder the silence.


A quiet stretch matters for every agent, but it matters most for top producers. We compared agents who were "busy and anchored," meaning they closed within three months and held three or more listings, with agents who had "gone quiet," meaning no closing in three or more months and an empty board.


Among high-volume producers doing 12 or more sides a year, busy agents switched at 2.3%. Quiet ones switched at 17.4%, eight times more often. The pattern holds further down the ladder, just less sharply. Mid-producers were 4.3 times more likely to move when quiet, and newer, lower-volume agents were 3.5 times more likely. When a 12-side agent goes silent, something has changed. That is a reason to call.


Most movers are not top producers.


Top producers get most of the attention, but they are a small share of who actually moves. Among all agents who switched brokerages, 49% produced under $1M in the prior 12 months and 37% produced $1M to $4M. Only 9% produced $4M to $8M, and just 5% produced more than $8M.

If your recruiting list starts and ends with the top of the production report, you are fishing in the smallest pond. The middle of the market is where the volume moves, and that is where our two personas live.


Persona 1: The newer up-and-coming agent.


This agent has been in the business less than three years. They closed more than $1.5M in the last 12 months, closed at least one listing, and their sales are up year over year. They have proven they can produce.


They are also in the years when agents move most. With a little success behind them, they start asking whether their brokerage can take them to the next level. Rising agents reassess hard, and they do it early. Yet most recruiters skip them because they are not on the top-producer list yet. That means less competition for your call.


The conversation is about growth. Ask where they want to be in two years. Talk about coaching, listing support, lead sources, and a path to a team or leadership role. They are building a career, not shopping for a split. Recruit them before their numbers make them obvious, and the production they build over the next decade builds at your firm.


Persona 2: The seasoned veteran in a slump.


This agent has been in the business three to ten years and has closed between $2M and $10M in volume. Right now, though, they have had no deals in 90 days or more and have no active listings.


This is the open window from our data. Nothing is anchoring them. They have a track record, but the last few months have been quiet, and quiet agents start asking questions about their brokerage. The slump also hides them. They drop off the top of the production report right when they become movable, so recruiters working from last year's list call them too early or never.


Approach them with respect, not pity. Acknowledge their track record and ask what would help them get back to their best year. Talk about marketing support, lead flow, coaching, and a fresh start. A downtrend is a leadership signal, so show them what leadership looks like at your firm. You get proven skills, a known book of business, and an agent with a reason to listen right now. Timing does the work that a bigger split usually has to.


A recruiting week that prepares itself.


Knowing who to call is half the job. The other half is doing it every week. The rhythm I recommend gives each day one focus, with the preparation done before you sit down.


Monday is for co-broke relationships. You start the week with a list of agents who co-broked with your firm last week, which of your agents they worked with, and on what transaction. These agents already have experience with your office, which gives you a natural reason to reach out, and the emails are drafted and the tasks set.

Tuesday is for the active pipeline. Who did you meet with, what did you promise, and who has a follow-up due? That includes agents who agreed to join but haven't completed the next step. Those commitments come forward so nothing slips.


Wednesday is for new prospects, and it is where the two personas earn their keep. You get five new agents who fit your criteria, each with a short brief and a suggested conversation angle. Five well-chosen names beat fifty random ones.


Thursday is for social relationships. For agents you have already talked to, you get their verified professional profiles and a few chances to connect. Friday is for recognition and review: a roundup of the week's notable listings and closings, congratulations drafts ready to send, and a list of any recruiting commitments still open before the weekend.


You decide how much comes back to you. Five prospects, three follow-ups, a handful of drafts. Match the workload to the time you actually have, and if more comes back than you can act on, cut the assignment. Small maintenance can run on its own, too. For example, every weekday at 10 a.m., the system can review up to ten agent records missing social links, add only verified public professional profiles, never overwrite existing values, and report what it updated and what it couldn't verify. That is a defined job with a result you can check.


You still decide how to engage, and the relationship is still yours. The preparation is simply already there.


Recruit on timing, not on lists.


The broker who called me had a market full of movement and no way to see it. Most brokerages are in the same spot, and the problem isn't motivation. It's the system.

Three shifts make the difference. Look earlier in careers, because agents move most in years one to three while recruiting attention doesn't peak until years 9 to 15. Watch the pipeline, not the title, because an empty board and a quiet quarter open the window and active listings close it. And spend your limited time on two personas, the rising newer agent and the veteran in a slump. Both are movable, and both are overlooked.


Maverick builds this into your week. Our platform tracks production patterns across more than 600,000 agents and flags Up & Comers, slowing veterans, and move signals, refreshed daily. You set the personas, the criteria, and the workload, and your recruiters spend their time on conversations instead of research.


See which agents in your market fit these two personas. Book a demo.


Smarter brokerage growth.